Private label agreements look simple on the surface. You find a manufacturer, they make the product, you sell it under your brand, and everyone makes money. Until something goes wrong.
In our practice, we regularly see business owners blindsided by disputes tied to private label products. Defective inventory. Regulatory violations. Customer claims. Chargebacks. Lost retailers. And suddenly, the business that thought it was “just the brand” is facing real legal exposure.
This article explains how B2B litigation arises from private label agreements, where liability actually lands, and what businesses can do to protect themselves before and after a dispute starts.
What Is a Private Label Agreement in Business Transactions
A private label agreement is a contract where one company manufactures a product that another company sells under its own brand. The seller controls the branding and marketing, and the vendor controls the manufacturing process.
These arrangements are common in food and beverage, cosmetics, supplements, consumer goods, and industrial products. They are also common sources of commercial litigation. Why? Because responsibility is rarely as clear as business owners assume.
Who Is Liable When a Private Label Product Fails
This is usually the first question business owners ask after a problem arises. Unfortunately, the answer is often “both parties.”
Even if the vendor manufactured the product, the brand owner is typically the party dealing with retailers, regulators, and end customers. That means the brand owner is often the first one sued.
From there, the dispute shifts into B2B litigation between the brand and the vendor over questions like:
- Who caused the defect
- Who violated regulatory requirements
- Who must pay for recalls, refunds, or damages
- Whether indemnification applies
- Whether the contract actually covers the problem at all
These cases frequently turn into breach of contract claims, indemnity disputes, and contribution claims between businesses.
Common Legal Disputes in Private Label Agreements
Private label litigation rarely starts with lawyers, but with operational problems that quickly escalate.
Some of the most common disputes we see include:
Defective or Nonconforming Products
Products that fail quality standards, do not match specifications, or cause customer harm can trigger massive downstream liability. If the agreement is vague about quality control, testing, or acceptance procedures, fault becomes harder to assign.
Regulatory Violations
In regulated industries, a vendor’s manufacturing mistake can expose the brand owner to fines, enforcement actions, or product bans. The vendor may argue the brand provided improper instructions. The brand may argue the vendor failed to comply with the law.
Indemnification Disputes
Many private label agreements contain indemnity clauses that look strong on paper but fall apart under scrutiny. Vendors may contest the scope of indemnity, claim notice was improper, or argue exclusions apply.
Supply Chain Disruptions and Lost Sales
If defective products cause retailers to pull inventory or terminate relationships, the brand may seek damages for lost profits. Vendors often push back hard on these claims.
Why Private Label Contracts Often Fail When Litigation Starts
Most private label agreements are drafted to get a deal done, not to withstand a dispute.
Problems commonly include:
- Indemnity clauses that are overly narrow or poorly defined
- No clear allocation of regulatory responsibility
- Weak quality control provisions
- No meaningful insurance requirements
- Ambiguous limitation of liability language
When litigation begins, courts do not rewrite contracts to make them fair. They enforce what is written. That is where many businesses realize too late that their agreement does not protect them the way they assumed.
Can a Brand Owner Sue a Vendor for Defective Private Label Products
Yes, and this is often the core of B2B litigation in private label disputes.
Common legal claims include:
- Breach of contract
- Breach of express or implied warranties
- Indemnification and contribution
- Negligence or negligent misrepresentation
- Fraud in extreme cases
However, the success of these claims depends heavily on contract language, evidence of causation, and how the parties documented issues as they arose.
Timing also matters. Delays in notice, continued sales after discovering defects, or inconsistent communications can undermine otherwise valid claims.
How Businesses Can Reduce Litigation Risk in Private Label Agreements
The best time to manage private label risk is before a problem exists.
Businesses should focus on:
- Clear specifications and testing requirements
- Defined regulatory responsibilities
- Real indemnification that actually covers foreseeable risks
- Insurance requirements aligned with real-world exposure
- Dispute resolution provisions that make sense for the business
Equally important is what happens after an issue arises. Early legal guidance can prevent a quality issue from becoming a full-scale commercial lawsuit.
When to Involve a Business Litigation Attorney
If you are facing product complaints, regulatory scrutiny, retailer disputes, or vendor pushback, waiting usually makes things worse.
A business litigation attorney can help evaluate:
- Whether your contract supports your position
- Whether indemnity obligations have been triggered
- How to preserve evidence and protect claims
- Whether early resolution is possible or litigation is unavoidable
Private label disputes move quickly and often involve significant financial exposure. The earlier strategy is applied, the more options remain available.
B2B Litigation and Private Label Disputes in Florida
Florida is a major hub for private label distribution, importation, and manufacturing relationships. That also means Florida courts regularly handle complex commercial disputes involving vendors, distributors, and brand owners.
Understanding how Florida contract law treats indemnity, damages, and commercial liability is critical when these cases arise.
Final Thoughts
Private label agreements can be powerful tools for growth. They can also become legal liabilities when responsibility is unclear and contracts are thin. At Ayala Law, we represent businesses in commercial disputes and transactional matters involving vendor agreements, product liability exposure, and B2B litigation.
If your vendor’s product has created a legal problem for your business, or if you are entering a private label arrangement and want to do it correctly, contact one of our experienced attorneys in Miami at 305-570-2208.
You can also contact our team directly at: arianna@ayalalawpa.com
Schedule a case evaluation online here.
[The opinions in this blog are not intended to be legal advice. You should consult with an attorney about the particulars of your case].
Subscribe to Our Blog
Stay informed with our latest blog posts delivered directly to your inbox. Gain valuable legal insights, tips, and advice from our seasoned attorneys.
